Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

2012 DAILYLAW 2018 (PNJ)

ABDULLA & ANR v. ANIL & ORS

FAO/5866/2012 · 2026-03-16

Harkesh Manuja

body2012

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

FAO Nos.5866 & 4972                                                                  ''''         ,,,,         //// 0 %* 0 %* 0 %* 0 %* )%* *" + )%* *" + )%* *" + )%* *" + 3333  - 14  - 14  - 14  - 14 !" #$ 4 !" #$ 4 !" #$ 4 !" #$ 4    5  5  5  5 6  6  6  6 % 5 %   %   2*%   2*%%    %   2*%%   2*%       7  7  7  7 @A  (   $ %( * *%++(   *2 ';'   . +*$)  (*  4972 of 2012 (O&M)                            * * * *39:: 39:: 39:: 39::*2 *2 *2 *2                               * * * */<=' /<=' /<=' /<='*2 *2 *2 *2                                       !" #$  %%&    !" #$  %%&    !" #$  %%&    !" #$  %%&    !" #$ ()%* *" +    !" #$ ()%* *" +    !" #$ ()%* *" +    !" #$ ()%* *" +    !" #$ (")-*  *    !" #$ (")-*  *    !" #$ (")-*  *    !" #$ (")-*  * %* -1*)% (&) % *2 %* -1*)% (&) % *2 %* -1*)% (&) % *2 %* -1*)% (&) % *2 !" #$ !" #$ !" #$ !" #$ + *%  % 2"--!" #$ ( + *%  % 2"--!" #$ ( + *%  % 2"--!" #$ ( + *%  % 2"--!" #$ ( 14(2 14*2 )%* *" +$ *2 14(2 14*2 )%* *" +$ *2 14(2 14*2 )%* *" +$ *2 14(2 14*2 )%* *" +$ *2 4 % *  %*2 4 % *  %*2 4 % *  %*2 4 % *  %*2 6   7 6   7 6   7 6   7 %8  %$ 4 &*+   %(") 4 &*+  *%  ))-- (   *39::* *%%)*  * '( /<=' %(# $7 % !4 &*+  *%%)*  */> "% +*$ *%  ))-- (   */<='* BBBB    4  4  4  4 (  (+*$$* *% %4.*   %(*" *2 +*$$*  %   - ($%(." -4"C2*%.%&( .  2(-  .1  +- ($ > ))  %   *  ++*"  *2  *2                 *2 *2 *2 *2';' ';' ';' ';'C ?E C ?E C ?E C ?E  F)) F)) F)) F))-- -- -- --   F )*  F )*  F )*  F )*   *2 *2 *2 *2';' ';' ';' ';'C ?E C ?E C ?E C ?E      F)) F)) F)) F))-- -- -- --   F )*   F )*   F )*   F )*        ;: ;: ;: ;:;' ;' ;' ;'';' ';' ';' ';':::: + + + +  ::::;;;;,,,,';': ';': ';': ';': *   .(  *   .(  *   .(  *   .(  ::::;;;;,,,,';': ';': ';': ';': $ ( $ ( $ ( $ ( ()%* *" + ()%* *" + ()%* *" + ()%* *" +  "-- "-- "-- "-- *22"-- *22"-- *22"-- *22"-- *  ))-(+ .- *  ))-(+ .- *  ))-(+ .- *  ))-(+ .-         :*2';'  ='*2';'  *$) 1(   *39::*2';'? *2';'  2*%())-%.( #+( ;9;3';').1-% &(14D%(." -GE  *39 ))--  8( #   +$  *2 (% *  . "-  ( (   $* 1  '? +( %  39::  *2 **% MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.16 18:21 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment FAO Nos.5866 & 4972 &(+"-%++(  .  )%2 +*$) (* * I+(& "     @'A   '4/=4:;;>J *2 ( ("(*  *2 ( &*-&( #+-- 2*% !"(+(* %2% +     @,A  )) +-($ )((*  " -%  %(." &(+"-% ++( #-(# %(&( # *2)-( # 42%))%+ )  )%+( # )%# #-(# ( %(& @/A  ( ).1- ';' )%($%(-1 -(.(-(1")*  4972 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment FAO Nos.5866 & 4972 )%$("$( ++( 2%" "*%(14  +-($ 4*  +*$) (* * *--1( H" ))-4"4+ !"     %(." -( -(              >  >  >  >  @3A     +*$) *--1( *2 !" +*$)  %(." -%%( #4%(  D$ %- % D$ %- % D$ %- % D$ %- % %)*%';; ';; ';; ';;<<<< * . ))-(  -* *"#" %. . 2(*2( +% %$*2!"#  "% +*  "% +*  "% +*  "% +* 4972 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment FAO Nos.5866 & 4972 @3A   I)   $ +- ($  % % %   "  4 % )*% %    * ($)"#   % % * .-                      @:A   ($)"#   2     -( .(-( 1 ( "% + *   --#  )*-(+1 %$ %8D ++*" ( ($ (* *2"+ +* +%   #( ;:;';;<   ( $ (21 * +*" - 2"% % )%*+   # (   "-1 ( "% )%*&    %%  (   -( #*&% ( #+* % 4972 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment FAO Nos.5866 & 4972 %* )  J+-($ +--2*%* (             @=A    ))%J.**8CE @9A   * */(%#% ( +* +% 4  . (*2&(  + -( .(-( 1 ")*  +* &( +( # &( ++*% + (  $ % %H"(% )%" -*2 %+ .)- + * %+  "% +* . -2  .( *%*&%4 *)* $*  %   () + *% " )%*&((*  *2  + *  &*(  (  " *%1 2 + &(  +4 2( ( "%%+ --2*% 4972 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment FAO Nos.5866 & 4972  Q    Q    Q    Q    @<A    *."  &( +*( ( 1*+"$ . *  * 2*%$ . +*2 1+ $)-*1$  (  *++"%% (   %$( (*  * ( + +*$)"(* *2! @;A   *% *% *% *%NNNN+C") %  )%  . +-*%4 3;L )%*2!"#$ D3 )% . + .+ & ($ *. (-(8  &( ) 4972 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment FAO Nos.5866 & 4972 $%% "%& . I)   "$ I) . @;A   "%&(& .1 # $)-*1$ (   $*%-   * $(   + )(*"*.-(# +*"- -2%*2 ()%* -"      ##( #%(+ ( * . . * - +-($ "+ *++")(* +* ((* *2  +* %(."(* #%%(# (2(+   * *"%( $ $ $ $ 4972 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment FAO Nos.5866 & 4972 -(&( #I) &(  )+"-( )  +*2 ( +*$4" Q  0 Q  0 Q  0 Q  0 @A   #*2) )%( +()-*2- *2 %$( (* . +-*%4  )  +   <1 %*2 # *  (  # ))-(  $"- )- +*2 $"- Q   Q   Q   Q  0 0 0 0 @'A   2" "% )%*)+   -     +* ( % (* * #*2  + )% + 4  ++(   *"# +*# &(  + ( (+   % * 4972 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment FAO Nos.5866 & 4972 ( +% ( ( +*$ D (* - "% D (* - "% D (* - "% D (* - "% *"%  $ ( ++*% ( #-14  ( %   * )  +1 Q    Q    Q    Q    @,A  "% $   %-  %$ $   %-  %$ $   %-  %$ $   %-  %$  "% + *  "% + *  "% + *  "% + * +*$)  (*  ) % -1 )) +*$)  (* " +* *% ("$(  .( #) % *2 @/A   & %-  ( -  * * * *       '  , * /  3  :::: * * * * 9 9 9 9 = = = = " " " " 9999 * * * * 4972 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment FAO Nos.5866 & 4972 <<<< * * * *  * * * *  $ $ $ $           ++   + +*$) %(." - @3A   &(*2*. *%& *%& *%& *%& C/E3, C/E3, C/E3, C/E3,)) 7%1  7%1  7%1  7%1    + * <L +-($ 2%*$  ( $*" %2%-* # *1- +-($ - @:A  ++ ))-- >+-($ H" "$*2+*$ */<='*2';' $%(4   ( -% **% 4972 of 2012 (O&M) **2* *%("$C /94;;;I' **2* *%("$C /94;;;I' **2* *%("$C /94;;;I' **2* *%("$C /94;;;I' *-*$) (* *-*$) (* *-*$) (* *-*$) (*  $*" %.1%(." - $*" %.1%(." - $*" %.1%(." - $*" %.1%(." -   ++*$) (*   ++*$) (*   ++*$) (*   ++*$) (*  ++*%( #-14 ))-- >+-($  ) (*  (   )%*)*%(*  -%  #%  *2 ( % K :L )% .%&(* $.1* N.- (* - "% +*$) 1($ (* - "% +*$) 1($ (* - "% +*$) 1($ (* - "% +*$) 1($ ))%*&( ".H" !"#$  1  *%4';/CE   1  *%4';/CE   1  *%4';/CE   1  *%4';/CE  <L )%  "$ *   $*"  *2( ("(* *2+-($ "  ( * )( ((  % $* #('L( %2%*$I)( *$ (* %$*" --."+2%*$  + ++*%( #-14))-(   ($ (--*( 2*%( *$) (* %( . ;'2(-(  +*2  ($(  ($)"#  % %++( -($%(." -4"( I'E I'E I'E I'E <:4;;;> <:4;;;> <:4;;;> <:4;;;>JJJJ =49349/> =49349/> =49349/> =49349/>JJJJ  '4/=4:;;> '4/=4:;;> '4/=4:;;> '4/=4:;;>JJJJ 34,=439/> 34,=439/> 34,=439/> 34,=439/>JJJJ  -- .  (- * %+(& .* -%1 %$(  .1  -%   "$ ( * H"(.-   !" -")%$*"%( D$") D$") D$") D$") ($( *%4 ($( *%4 ($( *%4 ($( *%4%)*%C';; C';; C';; C';;  (-D "$$ *%& D "$$ *%& D "$$ *%& D "$$ *%&   C(&(-E//,4   C(&(-E//,4   C(&(-E//,4   C(&(-E//,4"4( %  *2 +*$) (*  % * $)((* (--(%-(M(*  + $* 4  $ -- . )1. I)(%1*2)%(**2%$* 2%* " *2+*$) (* -%1)( ++*$) (*   *39::*2';')%2%%.1 (%$($*(2(+(* (  .*&4%))-(   "% +*$) 14.( #&*( %  ;9;3';' ) .1 ($*(2(*I ( (+ 10 .*& %  " (  ( ( ( ( C';;<E C';;<E C';;<E C';;<E %& %& %& %& ( *  + 1.- 2%*$ (* 1 (     (*2 1  +4 MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.16 18:21 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment FAO Nos.5866 & 4972 +-($ (( %(  @=A   *2    %+ %+ %+ %+::::4444';' ';' ';' ';':::: (8 0 0 4972 of 2012 (O&M) --. (-*  + $ %)+(2(( )%+  ( #$(+-- *"))-(+(* C            %)8( #>%*  >* %%)*%.-  >* +$*" *2+*$) (* -* +( #)%#%) CE4(2 14---* ()* C 7 E C 7 E C 7 E C 7 E          11 -* # )* MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.16 18:21 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment