Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2012 DAILYLAW 2018 (PNJ)
ABDULLA & ANR v. ANIL & ORS
FAO/5866/2012 · 2026-03-16
Harkesh Manuja
body2012
[ 2012 DAILYLAW 2018 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2012 DAILYLAW 2018 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
FAO Nos.5866 & 4972 '''' ,,,, //// 0 %* 0 %* 0 %* 0 %* )%* *" + )%* *" + )%* *" + )%* *" + 3333 - 14 - 14 - 14 - 14 !" #$ 4 !" #$ 4 !" #$ 4 !" #$ 4 5 5 5 5 6 6 6 6 % 5 % % 2*% 2*%% % 2*%% 2*% 7 7 7 7 @A ( $ %( * *%++( *2 ';' . +*$) (* 4972 of 2012 (O&M) * * * *39:: 39:: 39:: 39::*2 *2 *2 *2 * * * */<=' /<=' /<=' /<='*2 *2 *2 *2 !" #$ %%& !" #$ %%& !" #$ %%& !" #$ %%& !" #$ ()%* *" + !" #$ ()%* *" + !" #$ ()%* *" + !" #$ ()%* *" + !" #$ (")-* * !" #$ (")-* *
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
;: ;: ;: ;:;' ;' ;' ;'';' ';' ';' ';':::: + + + + ::::;;;;,,,,';': ';': ';': ';': * .( * .( * .( * .( ::::;;;;,,,,';': ';': ';': ';': $ ( $ ( $ ( $ ( ()%* *" + ()%* *" + ()%* *" + ()%* *" + "-- "-- "-- "-- *22"-- *22"-- *22"-- *22"-- * ))-(+ .- * ))-(+ .- * ))-(+ .- * ))-(+ .- :*2';' ='*2';' *$) 1( *39::*2';'? *2';' 2*%())-%.( #+( ;9;3';').1-% &(14D%(." -GE *39 ))-- 8( # +$ *2 (% * . "- ( ( $* 1
'? +( % 39:: *2 **% MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.16 18:21 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
FAO Nos.5866 & 4972 &(+"-%++( . )%2 +*$) (* * I+(& " @'A '4/=4:;;>J *2 ( ("(* *2 ( &*-&( #+-- 2*% !"(+(* %2% + @,A )) +-($ )((* " -% %(." &(+"-% ++( #-(# %(&( # *2)-( # 42%))%+ ) )%+( # )%# #-(# ( %(& @/A ( ).1- ';' )%($%(-1 -(.(-(1")* 4972 of 2012 (O&M)
4(+*++"%%* ;:;';; 2%% .1 "% + *$) * #%*" $*" "-(.-*.%"+ -% %(." -4 &( ($ +*$) (* 4-* #(( % *2 +-($ )((* (-- ( +" -- #*H" "$*2+*$) * + % .( # +"-- *" 2 ))-- .( # )% *2 " % +(* :: *2 ** - 8( # +*$) (* * ( (+ *++"%% * ;:;' ( #*2%)* *J%(&%*2 #*2)%(4-% %(. %+(( #*%---*+"$ % ;9;3';' #% ( # %#%) 2% *-( # %(&% %(&( #$ ( # ##%(& *2 2*%$ -% %(." -4 "% +* -1 * #%*" -% ( "%%)(2+ ;;<4% */<='*2';
$) 14 (-( # H" "$ %.1-% %(." - ($)"# %4 #% "$ %K:L)% "$2%*$ +"- %-(M(* * )) (* 4%"48 ")*# 2%*$ *39:: *2 ';' 2 + .
"- (4 ( (" **% (+- +4 <99 .2*% ++*" *2 ( ( $* ;';;<4 --#-1 " * % *2*22 ( #&(+- . %(." -2%$ +%1(" %1&( +.%*"#* %+* # +*$) (* 4 *(+ ( % *2 *22 ( # &(+- * (* % ;9;3'; *$) 1)%2%% */<=' %(." - %% ( 2 ( # +H"("*%)1$ 2
';' $ *2 -( $ *2 )-4 % ' 2*% $**% . ( " +*%4 * . ';' ='*2 # *2 MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.16 18:21 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
FAO Nos.5866 & 4972 )%$("$( ++( 2%" "*%(14 +-($ 4* +*$) (* * *--1( H" ))-4"4+ !" %(." -( -(
>
>
>
> @3A +*$) *--1( *2 !" +*$) %(." -%%( #4%( D$ %- % D$ %- % D$ %- % D$ %- % %)*%';; ';; ';; ';;<<<< * . ))-( -* *"#" %. . 2(*2( +% %$*2!"# "% +* "% +* "% +* "% +* 4972 of 2012 (O&M)
(* *"% )*-(+1+ "( ($(* *( "% "($)"# %%& *% 42(- *39: * #%*" $*"
" *+*$$ "%( +--2*%%$( (* *2-(.
H" +1 *2 H" "$ *2 +*$) -(# *2 - -# -)*( (* > > > > % +*" - 2*% ))-- (* % .1 - % H" +* % %1 * - (* " % * *% (+- ( ))-1( # $"- ()-(%*2 ) ( &( *2 - - ( * .1 %$ * % & -( % %$ * % & -( % %$ * % & -( % %$ * % & -( % <C,E C(&(-E==4 <C,E C(&(-E==4 <C,E C(&(-E==4 <C,E C(&(-E==4 ))%*) 2"% % %#" ( +* -* %2(#"% * ( (* * %." &( +* %+*% .-( ( ( +*$4& ( + * " #$ *2 * N.-")%$ %)*% ';'C'E C(& ';'C'E C(& ';'C'E C(& ';'C'E C(& + +-- $"+)%(*% * -- +* +% #( % %& *. ( * I 9::*2';'8( # +$ % .1 - % %(." - -*"22% .1 $* ( .(-( 1*2 ( "%% -- $) (* % .1 - % >+- ($ &$ -1 +* * *% ++( - ($ %(." - )%( +()-#*&% ( # $ (+- + ".$( )( + .( #';1 % 1 * N.-)I*"% ( + % )*% *%)*% (* * % )*% *%)*% (* * % )*% *%)*% (* * % )*% *%)*% (* * %*)%( $"- ()-(%*29 %H"(% +*$ *2 + %* # % 2" "%)%*)+ #% .-( ($* -1 % ( # *2 (-1
#%4 )%$((.- *"% ( *&(& (* *&(& (* *&(& (* *&(& (* C(&(-E99' C(&(-E99' C(&(-E99' C(&(-E99' 3 *2 %( # *2 - % ." - $ %*2 *2 %4G %4G %4G %4G "(% * #-1 4 .-( (* - (* - (* - (* - MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.16 18:21 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment FAO Nos.5866 & 4972 @3A I) $ +- ($ % % % " 4 % )*% % * ($)"# % % * .- @:A ($)"# 2 -( .(-( 1 ( "% + * --# )*-(+1 %$ %8D ++*" ( ($ (* *2"+ +* +% #( ;:;';;< ( $ (21 * +*" - 2"% % )%*+ # ( "-1 ( "% )%*& %% ( -( #*&% ( #+* % 4972 of 2012 (O&M) % +*" - ".$( $+ (+ --1 ))-( ( *" +* %-& -# -)*( (* "% %$* " % +* & (* - *% (* -* *2 -*& 2 * -* % ( ) % ."( .-1$* (2( + $*" % +*" -2*% ))-- O % *--1 " " ( .- -( 1 ")* ( "%% )( % *2 ++( % %*"# +H" " +-* G4 %")* )*-(+1 "++ +-- (* "-1 * #( %( #>% )*% " *%( 1 +(%+"$ +4 ( "% * %( . +*2 & -( % ".$( %(&% ( I) % 42 (- * (+ %# "% * %-& 4 * * * %*2 *22 -( # ))-- ( -( .(-( 1 % + " --( .(-( 1*2 ( "%%" "+ (* * % )%* +* ( %( # ) +1 *2 $*%4"%# $ #%
$*" "+ 2" % - I) 4 -* 22+ (* 4 % *2 ( % )%$(4 ( )% 1 +*$) (* . + * ! "% +*$) 1+* .- ( -( $"+ %(." % .( # * ".(( # +* %+ %#" )%$("$ 2*%
" (+ (* *"% ( -(+1**+ +--.( ((* ** -1*( "%."-** -- )%(*% * ++( "%% * * . +*$)-- -( 22+(&)*-(+1-% * % &( # +* * * "*2)%*&( #&( * + %)* *' )+(2(+ ( #&(+-4%(." -#%& 1 +* %%1 * - )%( +() %**%(+-+ 4
* - 2 *" *2 % !" ." - + *2 % " * * % * . (+- (+--1 &-1 +()- +4 MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.16 18:21 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
FAO Nos.5866 & 4972 %* ) J+-($ +--2*%* ( @=A ))%J.**8CE @9A * */(%#% ( +* +% 4 .
(*2&( + -( .(-( 1 ")* +* &( +( # &( ++*% + ( $ % %H"(% )%" -*2 %+ .)- + * %+ "% +* . -2 .( *%*&%4 *)* $* % () + *% " )%*&((* *2 + * &*( ( " *%1 2 + &( +4 2( ( "%%+ --2*% 4972 of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
%&%1$"+ & (- .- ($ &( +* )%* "+ ))%*)%( -$ %( - .%*"# * %+*% (* :;,';;< % & %)* ( -- - . 2(+( - ( "% ( " % 1 +- ($ I+) .1 )%*&( # . +*2 1"+-# --1 $((. %(." -2 ( #-(.(-(1")* 5
( # ( 1 #* ( * ( # %* &% "%% ( # (.- MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.16 18:21 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
FAO Nos.5866 & 4972 Q Q Q Q @<A *." &( +*( ( 1*+"$ . * * 2*%$ . +*2 1+ $)-*1$ ( *++"%% ( %$( (* * ( + +*$)"(* *2! @;A *% *% *% *%NNNN+C") % )% . +-*%4 3;L )%*2!"#$ D3 )% . + .+ & ($ *. (-(8 &( ) 4972 of 2012 (O&M)
)% +4(+*$* % ($*2++( P*& (+ "%*2+*"%*% . )%*"+*$* %( %* .- . ( 2*% ( 1+*# )%**2(%#%*( ( % 2""% 8)( # ( 1% ';;< .( &( # %# *2 *(* - ( +*$ ( "+ + +*$*2+K,4:; 2!"+*$) (* * N.- ")%$ *"% (
")%E-( ++ 4 "+(* 2*--* (22 L * . "+ )%* #$ (+"--*"" %5J 3 0% + . % 4 "+(* 2*--* (2 +-*%4 *%$--14 3;L ( "+ +"(("$. +-*% & *%(4%(-*)*(.
($4( (+& +* %(."(* *.+"%(+--1"%%4".!+ -(8-1*&(* ( +*$ $*%-* (--.+* (% &( + * +* %%14 .%*% ) 4 .+" 1 (-- ( %+*%+ &%4%( *$%(-*%)+( *%"()"%"( #4 *% (+$(+"*%2""%&*+( ( # ( )%*)+(& ( +*$ % ( #*%-(8-(***2#( ( &( 2+ ++( #% * )%&(-( # % +4 -% %(." - %(# 4:;;>J)%$* 2*%)"%)* + *2 $ %- %$ $ %- %$ $ %- %$ $ %- %$ . +-*% +-($ (22% )%( +()- ( %#% * - -(&( # I) -& .
+-*% +-($ % (22% )%( +()- ( %#%
"+ )%* - -(&( # I) *%*"- *) $*%* ($ (.(-(1*2(#( #$%%(( (* *)% CE (.-( #(-(8 +*&( +*+* %%142 (-- *.+* (%) (%) . + (% (-- * . +* (% (% . ( ) % ( #4 6
+(2(+ % (* ( 2"- ( 2*% (#-1 *2 % * & % % * 4 ($-2 *% -(8-1 2% +*2 % #4 *% MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.16 18:21 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
FAO Nos.5866 & 4972 $%% "%& . I)
"$ I) . @;A "%&(& .1 # $)-*1$ ( $*%- * $( + )(*"*.-(# +*"- -2%*2 ()%* -" ##( #%(+ ( * . . * - +-($ "+ *++")(* +* ((* *2 +* %(."(* #%%(# (2(+ * *"%( $ $ $ $ 4972 of 2012 (O&M)
%%(4 *% . ) * 2
"%&(&.1)% (.-( #4* -1 ) 4 3;L *"- . I) *2. +-*%3;L+ %2$(-1*2.
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
#+(%+"$ + "+ ( " (* *"*- *"- & "$ -2 %*2() % - ( * .1 * N.- ")%$ ")% E "+ (* * % )%* 7 ( % * -(&( # &%4 $*2 - %# -(&( # -1 (-- ( " % 2(-( - 2( -12*% * . ")* 2%*$ +( - (* 4 "$ %$ * - MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.16 18:21 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
FAO Nos.5866 & 4972 -(&( #I) &( )+"-( ) +*2 ( +*$4" Q 0 Q 0 Q 0 Q 0 @A #*2) )%( +()-*2- *2 %$( (* .
+-*%4 ) + <1 %*2 # * ( # ))-( $"- )- +*2 $"- Q Q Q Q 0 0 0 0 @'A 2" "% )%*)+ - +* ( % (* * #*2 + )% + 4 ++( *"# +*# &( + ( (+ % * 4972 of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
+ 4 + 4 %2*%4 $"- ()-(% ))-(+ . (*"%4( (+* (%*)( (* *2 +*$)"(* *2 +*$) (* %(." -
( *$8( # 1((* *% *2 + ( .1 * + ( %H"(% * . 8 ( %+*$) (* 4&( #%#%* +(* *2& +$ ( -(2 " ($*2 * *(* - . ( 2*% 1*"2"-#*2++- #( 2"- $)-*1$ )%*#%( 8
( #( 1 -"%- *$ +* - %)* *2 #*2 +.- ( (* 4 * ( % -- ( * * *2 *2 -%-1 (& MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.16 18:21 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment FAO Nos.5866 & 4972 ( +% ( ( +*$ D (* - "% D (* - "% D (* - "% D (* - "% *"% $ ( ++*% ( #-14 ( % * ) +1 Q Q Q Q @,A "% $ %- %$ $ %- %$ $ %- %$ $ %- %$ "% + * "% + * "% + * "% + * +*$) (* ) % -1 )) +*$) (* " +* *% ("$( .( #) % *2 @/A & %- ( - * * * * ' , * / 3 :::: * * * * 9 9 9 9 = = = = " " " " 9999 * * * * 4972 of 2012 (O&M) *$ &( *2 - - ( * "% +*$) 1($( & % "% +*$) 1($( & % 1 "% +*$) 1($( & % "% +*$) 1($( & % 1 ( ))%*)%( * #% ( +%$ K/;L*2 % 2" "% )%*)+ 2*% ) "% %$*%4( &( *2 !" #$ %$ * % %$ * % %$ * % %$ * %4 % 1 % 1 % 1 % 1 (N (N (N (N * & ( % 7 "%G4 * & ( % 7 "%G4 * & ( % 7 "%G4 * & ( % 7 "%G4 %)* % " %+* & (* - ))-- >+- ($ % "4 " %2" % - 94;;; * " *2 <:4;;;> *2 + % -* ( - 2*%2(- &( *2 (+"(* $ % 2*% #% *2+*$) (* ( "% "% "% "% " - +*$*2+ /;L " "%
%*)+ * - +*$C /,4';;R =4 "+ (* C/;LE +*$C :;4/9;O '/4< * *2 +*$ 2 % ))-1( # $ * *2 +*$ 2 % ))-1( # $ * *2 +*$ 2 % ))-1( # $ * *2 +*$ 2 % ))-1( # $ 9 )% #*2<1 %C,:4'99I 9 )% #*2<1 %C,:4'99I 9 )% #*2<1 %C,:4'99I 9 )% #*2<1 %C,:4'99I " % -I) " % -I) " % -I) " % -I) **2 **2 **2 **2 .1 * N.-")%$*"% 1 ( 1 ( 1 ( 1 (4C';=E::9;4G 4C';=E::9;4G 4C';=E::9;4G 4C';=E::9;4G ( (* * % 2" "% )%*)+ * (* -( +*$*2 + )"%)* *2 +*$)" ( # -* #$ *2 * N.-)I*"% (N (N (N (N + C")% E D ( D ( D ( D ( )*% C';'E =9 C';'E =9 C';'E =9 C';'E =9 % -*%H"(% *. - ( - 2*% 94;;;>J ;;;>J * % -**2 * ;>JC /94;;;I'E ))-- 2(-( -+* *% ("$ %( .*&4 ))-- >+- ($ ( 2*--* ( #$ %5J $*" C( E $*" C( E $*" C( E $*" C( E /,4';;>J =4'9;>J =4'9;E :;4/9;>J '/4<'>J 4<'E ,:4'99>J $"- ()-(% *2 $"- ()-(% *2 $"- ()-(% *2 $"- ()-(% *2 I9E I9E I9E I9E :43,49/> :43,49/> :43,49/> :43,49/>JJJJ 94;;;> 94;;;> 94;;;> 94;;;>JJJJ 94;;;> 94;;;> 94;;;> 94;;;>JJJJ 9 "% ( ( )+ *2 "% ( ( ( (
( =9;4 =9;4 =9;4 =9;4 *2 - 4 MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.16 18:21 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
FAO Nos.5866 & 4972 <<<< * * * * * * * * $ $ $ $ ++ + +*$) %(." - @3A &(*2*. *%& *%& *%& *%& C/E3, C/E3, C/E3, C/E3,)) 7%1 7%1 7%1 7%1 + * <L +-($ 2%*$ ( $*" %2%-* # *1- +-($ - @:A ++ ))-- >+-($ H" "$*2+*$ */<='*2';' $%(4 ( -% **% 4972 of 2012 (O&M)
**2* *%("$C/94;;;I' **2* *%("$C/94;;;I' **2* *%("$C/94;;;I' **2* *%("$C/94;;;I' *-*$) (* *-*$) (* *-*$) (* *-*$) (* $*" %.1%(." - $*" %.1%(." - $*" %.1%(." - $*" %.1%(." - ++*$) (* ++*$) (* ++*$) (* ++*$) (* ++*%( #-14 ))-- >+-($ ) (* ( )%*)*%(* -% #% *2 ( % K :L )% .%&(* $.1* N.- (* - "% +*$) 1($ (* - "% +*$) 1($ (* - "% +*$) 1($ (* - "% +*$) 1($ ))%*&( ".H" !"#$ 1 *%4';/CE 1 *%4';/CE 1 *%4';/CE 1 *%4';/CE <L )% "$ * $*" *2( ("(* *2+-($
" ( * )( (( % $* #('L( %2%*$I)( *$ (* %$*" --."+2%*$ + ++*%( #-14))-( ($ (--*( 2*%( *$) (* %( .
;'2(-( +*2 ($( ($)"# % %++( -($%(." -4"( I'E I'E I'E I'E <:4;;;> <:4;;;> <:4;;;> <:4;;;>JJJJ =49349/> =49349/> =49349/> =49349/>JJJJ '4/=4:;;> '4/=4:;;> '4/=4:;;> '4/=4:;;>JJJJ 34,=439/> 34,=439/> 34,=439/> 34,=439/>JJJJ -- . (- * %+(& .* -%1 %$( .1 -% "$ ( * H"(.- !" -")%$*"%( D$") D$") D$") D$") ($( *%4 ($( *%4 ($( *%4 ($( *%4%)*%C';; C';; C';; C';;
(-D
"$$ *%& D
"$$ *%& D
"$$ *%& D
"$$ *%& C(&(-E//,4 C(&(-E//,4 C(&(-E//,4 C(&(-E//,4"4( % *2 +*$) (* % * $)((* (--(%-(M(* + $* 4 $ -- . )1. I)(%1*2)%(**2%$* 2%*
" *2+*$) (* -%1)( ++*$) (* *39::*2';')%2%%.1 (%$($*(2(+(* ( .*&4%))-( "% +*$) 14.( #&*( % ;9;3';' ) .1 ($*(2(*I ( (+ 10
.*& %
" ( ( ( ( ( C';;<E C';;<E C';;<E C';;<E %& %& %& %& ( * + 1.- 2%*$ (* 1 ( (*2 1 +4 MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.16 18:21 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
FAO Nos.5866 & 4972 +-($ (( %( @=A *2 %+ %+ %+ %+::::4444';' ';' ';' ';':::: (8 0 0 4972 of 2012 (O&M)
--. (-* + $ %)+(2(( )%+ ( #$(+-- *"))-(+(* C %)8( #>%* >* %%)*%.- >* +$*" *2+*$) (* -* +( #)%#%) CE4(2 14---* ()* C7 E C7 E C7 E C7 E 11
-* # )* MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.16 18:21 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment