Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

2008 DAILYLAW 2291 (PNJ)

KRISHNA DEVI AND ORS. v. SUKHBIR SINGH AND ORS.

FAO/3812/2008 · 2026-05-12

Sudeepti Sharma

body2008

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

FAO-3812-2008 (O&M) -1-        FAO-3812-2008 (O&M)              ! Reserved on:- 10.04.2026 "  #$! %&'()*()(+  !! %&'()*()(+                 ,%  -.,     ,                          !!!!    ,     "    #  $%  &  '( ' '')  #    % % "%#  % %  % %% %  *% ++    ,%  -)) .  / "%# 01    % $   %      2 -3'''4 $ &% % 5( 67         8  %   ,%  %    (  ''+    %   %% %    % %  9   % & #   "%#   % %       %  9 %  #      :  #% MOHD AYUB 2026.05.12 18:27 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. FAO-3812-2008 (O&M) -2-  ,  .  .    "      %       #   "%#  %   & %    #  "        # &     % #     & 3             &  $    % & %  %$ % "     %%     6        %     &   %  &% % # % ../  ,   + ;0# *    %    Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another 01())23+#"4 #"'('5 % &  &    %           <30                       !      "                 #  $  %                  &      '    $%!  ! !  !   % !      "     %       (   )*+,-  !             .,%()*+/-!       /0% ( )*+1- !     " " MOHD AYUB 2026.05.12 18:27 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. FAO-3812-2008 (O&M) -3- 31 !         %  !     2   %   %  134              " %         !     ! %             % !    )-    #     5%     %   #   !  !         !      2     %   !      %   !        %  %    32        % !       % 134!         "     134     &!%!           %    !  ! !    (    %        "    (      !   # !(  * * * * * * 42.            $ )/-  )        6% #$   $  -%!  !  MOHD AYUB 2026.05.12 18:27 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. FAO-3812-2008 (O&M) -4-      *7)  *1.3 .* .1  -%      %  8(*9 .0,3  %8(*0,*,1  %8(*1,0/3  %8( *//*/1  % 8(*,/013  % !     %  %8(**1*11  %8(: 1003  %8(90*01   8(10093   ( ;0# *    %    National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. 01()'63'++7)5  %%  &  *% ++ +  +)    ,%  -))   &%$  . 1 8 %    %%$ =  % %%> .1 *%  %% %$  $  > . 1 $    #%   %$ %%> .81 2# %$   %         %    = &% %> .?1 @      $%     % $ &%  A#>    %=  "  %   A $ %     <52. ;  conventional heads %!      !  !"  < =2     <.1%333  !     " %  <  *%33%333 !    <*%33%333!                  " <   > %  !  MOHD AYUB 2026.05.12 18:27 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. FAO-3812-2008 (O&M) -5-         %  %           !        ? #    %     '   ; '                     "%   # %                              ! %    !    "                  % !       #   #    '! %       #   %! #    "  2        %  %  %         "        <*1%333% </3%333    <*1%333                           @      ( ' (  #      !                  !    '                    *34             !          A A A A A MOHD AYUB 2026.05.12 18:27 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. FAO-3812-2008 (O&M) -6- 59.3    %    134      !   %!       !   ! /3  %         ,34%   !  !/313  2  !  ! 1303  %     *14 ;              " 59.42  !  (  )-  "   %    /34     !  ! !   ! /3   ;   .14! !  !  /313   *34! !  ! 1303                    "  59.55      %      " %        ,3,.  B C! !      59.6.                B D !   /.  59.7           59.8<      %  %   %    "   < MOHD AYUB 2026.05.12 18:27 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. FAO-3812-2008 (O&M) -7- *1%333%</3%333 <*1%333           *34    E ) ;0# *    %    ,84"#"$  49.:4:!# 4:;#;"# 4 ;"0()'71'73 '<)5 %%$ ""4 1#"3  "9;:1#"3   & $%$ % 2          F21;$  @ $    = !     !       !                       2    %G G    !   G    G%  G    G%    G  G  !     %  % %%  %     % !           % !   "   !    .**Spousal consortium              (! !  !        G  %  %   %  %       G .*. Parental consortium          % G   %  %  %   %  %     G .*,Filial consortium                ;      MOHD AYUB 2026.05.12 18:27 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. FAO-3812-2008 (O&M) -8-      #                       $     %  %           22$               !     8    ! (      H   "      !       8        !            !                 %   %            238B  ;                    %       2     !                 %      %      !           !  !         ;;!& $  !      &!%!    !      !       !      24      !   !      !      G  G  !    =2  MOHD AYUB 2026.05.12 18:27 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. FAO-3812-2008 (O&M) -9-  %!     !       %     < /3%333         -     % $ &     &   # %$ 2 ''''4   &% &:%$     &%  % %%$  %$        4 2 B% 2% %     #%  % %  %    * %% ?=  #   "%#  ;&   "%#  &%  %$%$ $   # %$%$  %#   % %#   #%%    %     2 '''4   $ &: &% % %   & % ' "%   %   % %&   %      #    #%    &   %  * %% ?=  %$    %    %   %=  2 ''''4        &   %$  # & &       %        &  % (*=%  #              &     "%#    %  %$ 4   =%  %  43 @    "%#    %  %$ %%  + %  6        & &      # &       % C        &       = %  & % " & 9 % % $  %   MOHD AYUB 2026.05.12 18:27 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. FAO-3812-2008 (O&M) -10-  .   3  %&   & % & #  ;0# *    %  #   A $    % & " &  '( ' '') % %% %$ " %  %   %     %    Sr. No. Heads Compensation Awarded    2 ''''4  @    567 2 6''4 .67  ''''1 8 % &  =%  43 2 64 .6'' D 431 3 "  2 -(64 .6''61 6  %% 6 +   8 2 +)(6''4 .-(6 D  D 61 ( E  ? 2 6'''4 ) @  ?= 2 6'''4 - E  %  3'''' =  *  3'''' =  @%% 3'''' =  2 '''''4 '   4: '2>'6>*))?&  !#$:    & #  "%#  <>2@>)))?&  ;$!4 # '*>(<>*))?&1'2>'6>*))&<>2@>)))3 6 *    %  %    # ;0# *    % Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma ()'2<'6+  R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation 1()((3* #"4 #"')6> %  $  % 5 -7            %%$  % %% %    % %F% MOHD AYUB 2026.05.12 18:27 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. FAO-3812-2008 (O&M) -11- +  %&   #       % %  %      % $ &% % &%  "%#  &%%  %  &    %    % A $ " "%#  % %  %#       % $ &% % %      %4   %  #   "%#  % % &  '( ' '') " %4  %   % % #:   %   "%#  ( %$ %%.1 %     %  '()*()(+    1   ,3  +;         # +(  #  I  #        I+ MOHD AYUB 2026.05.12 18:27 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment.