FAO NO.4610 OF 20



                              ((((     ))))     //// 0&- 0&- 0&- 0&- +&-!-#!3 +&-!-#!3 +&-!-#!3 +&-!-#!3 4444 ,15 ,15 ,15 ,15 "#$%! 5 "#$%! 5 "#$%! 5 "#$%! 5   6  6  6  6 7  7  7  7 &! 6 &   &   2-&    -!        8 8 8 8 9:  1 ;<;4(;;=5+ .&'*15 ?  & 3-%+!*-! - 2&-%  -2 *!"#&* #22& (((;;4     9(:   Tribunal praying 2008 (O&M) 
    
    
    
    
 
 
 
        - - - -////                    !"#$%!  &&'  !"#$%!  &&'  !"#$%!  &&'  !"#$%!  &&'  !  !  !  !"#$%! *+&-!-#!3 "#$%! *+&-!-#!3 "#$%! *+&-!-#!3 "#$%! *+&-!-#!3  !"#$%! *#+,--  !"#$%! *#+,--!  !"#$%! *#+,--  !"#$%! *#+,--! &-!,1-+&*'+&-2"#$% &-!,1-+&*'+&-2"#$% &-!,1-+&*'+&-2"#$% &-!,1-+&*'+&-2"#$% 3-& &2#,,"#$%! * 3-& &2#,,"#$%! * 3-& &2#,,"#$%! * 3-& &2#,,"#$%! * 15*2!15-2+&-!-#!3%! 15*2!15-2+&-!-#!3%! 15*2!15-2+&-!-#!3%! 15*2!15-2+&-!-#!3%! -2 -2 -2 -2 ! 5! &-!&-2 ! 5! &-!&-2 ! 5! &-!&-2 ! 5! &-!&-2 7 
8 7 
8 7 
8 7 
8 &8#! , -$5'-32-& &*#+5'-3 -&++,,!  -! 2-&&+-! !  CCC    5  5  5  5 1 1-2+&! ++,53,,!$ .1,&! --&33* &*.#! ,DE5 &.1 ! %-#!   -  ++,,! @3,*%!  ,-!$ -2 2*,*!$-2 3,*% +**-!*,,* & .1 *% *!  %--& '*3# appellant, being injured filed a aying for grant of compensation on ac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iled a claim petition before the learne on account of injuries suffered by hi 1   !>2-&   !!#% ! -2  -! learned by him MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.27 17:01 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment FAO NO.4610 OF 20 in a motor vehicu and negligent dr driven by respond 9):  2 by both the parti conclusion that th respondent No. 2 9/:  *! appeal came to compensation. Fa negligence of the learned Tribunal not being repeated                @ @ @ @ 94:   award on the gro grossly inadequa sustained. It was principles govern appellant suffered shoulder arising resulting in recurr contended that th insufficient and compensation un 2008 (O&M) vehicular accident which took place o ent driving of vehicle bearing regi espondent No. 2/driver. 2&going through the claim petitio e parties, learned Tribunal vide awar t the accident occurred on account No. 2 and awarded Rs.95,000/- as com *!$aggrieved of the aforesaid aw e to be preferred by the appellan on. Facts as specified in the claim of the driver been recorded in favour bunal being not in dispute, therefore, peated here.                        @
 @
 @
 @
 &!  counsel for the appellant/ he ground that the compensation gra dequate and disproportionate to the It was contended that the ld. Tribu governing award of just compensatio ffered 25% permanent disability due rising from a malunited clavicle fr recurrent loss of consciousness and m that the sum of Rs.50,000/- awarded and that the ld. Tribunal erred on under the heads of medical expe lace on 22.11.2005 while alleging ras g registration No.RJ-05-P-1281 bein petition and evaluating the evidence le award dated 07.05.2008; arrived at ccount of rash and negligent driving o as compensation. aid award dated 07.05.2008; the prese ppellant/claimant for enhancement o claim petition and the issue regardin favour of the appellant/claimant by th efore, for the sake of brevity, those a                     ellant/claimant assailed the impugne n granted by the learned Tribunal wa to the nature and extent of injurie Tribunal failed to apply the settle ensation, particularly inasmuch as th y due to restricted movement of the le icle fracture, along with head injur and mental impairment. Further, it wa warded towards disability was whol erred in not awarding appropria l expenses, loss of income, and futu 2 ing rash 1 being ence led ed at a iving of present ent of garding t by the hose are     pugned was injuries settled as the the left injury t was wholly ropriate d future MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.27 17:01 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment FAO NO.4610 OF 20 earning capacity compensation to R 9B:  *!3 &'*35 - ' ,&! &*.#! , 3-%+!*-! 9<: 
 .--K-23 ++,,!  9=:  2 & $#*!32& -#&
!? "8 ? "8# ? "8 ? "8# -#&,*- ! *!"#&* ?B *!"# 3# 3# 3# 3# >*E  >**E ' >E >.E >***E -! -! -! -! 2008 (O&M) acity by applying a suitable multipli on to Rs.10,00,000/- was prayed for. *!35&*!-&+&! *-!-! '& 3-!*&*!$  23 5  ! ,5&+-! ! '. !, *-!5%& &-!%&* '&,&! 3-#!,2-& 
2*! 2-&3*!&$#%!  2-& &%*!*!$  L#! #% - 2&-%+&*!3*+,,*- !*! "8#%&'"18#%&!  &D "8#%&'"18#%&!  &D "8#%&'"18#%&!  &D "8#%&'"18#%&!  &D !#! & *33-%+! ?B   #! & *3 3-% *!"#&13&2-,,- *!$6 3#!*&1%$>+3*,%$ 3#!*&1%$>+3*,%$ 3#!*&1%$>+3*,%$ 3#!*&1%$>+3*,%$  N+! &,*!$ - &% &!+-&*-!5!-#&**!$2-- >**E - -2 &!*!$ >!  -& ' %!-. !*!"#&  --2&!*!$#&*!$+  --22##&&!*!$-!3 >***E ##&%*3,N+! -! -! -! -!JJJJ+3#!*&1%$>! &, +3#!*&1%$>! &, +3#!*&1%$>! &, +3#!*&1%$>! &, ultiplier; accordingly, enhancement o  -!. ,2-2&+-! ! +  +&  2*! *!$ &3-& .1 ,"-*! ,1! '&,,1,*.,-+ &* ++,,! ! +&#++ '!3.1,&! -#!,2-&  -2 3-%+!*-!5 * * ! *, *!*%*,&3.1-!M.,+ &D &D &D &D&+-&>(;E)/) >(;E)/) >(;E)/) >(;E)/) !*-!*-.  &2-&+&-! 3-%+!*-! *  & *! +&-! $E $E $E $E %! 5 -+*,*A*-!5 %*3*! 2--5! %*3,,! -#N+! *#& & $*!E *3  *!"#& -# &53-%+&**!$6 +&*--2&%! O !33-#! -2+&%! ! *.*,*1 ,%$E ,%$E ,%$E ,%$E 3 ment of +* 1  -+1 +&J -& *, - +N /) /) /) /) -! , &-! , *3*! 5 *#& -#, MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.27 17:01 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment FAO NO.4610 OF 20 >*'E *!"# >'E >'*E
!&- #!  3 >.E5 +&% >!         ?  ?  ?  ?   9I: 
! was about 40 yea as a labourer earn or documentary e duly established remained hospita losing his earning of documentary p when the nature o Furthermore, the in nature, eviden Supreme Court i Kumar Yadav & proof of income, time cannot be ab 2008 (O&M) >*'E %$2-&+*!5#22&*!$ *!"#&*  --2%!**>! @-&,- >'*E --2N+3*-!-2,*2>
!&-#*! +&-! ,*!"#&1353- #! &>*E5>**E>E! >*'E
 &&*+3*2*3%*3,'* 3,*%! 53-%+!*-! *,, >.E5>***E5>'E! >'*E&,*!$-,- +&%! !  *.*,*15 2##& %* >! @-&,--2+&-+3-2%&&*$              
 D  
 D  
 D  
 D !+&! 35as per the claim 0 years of age at the time of the accid er earning approximately ₹3,000/- per ntary evidence was adduced in suppo ished that the appellant sustained g ospitalized, and was incapacitated fo arning capacity during such time. In th tary proof cannot be a ground to den ature of injuries and period of treatmen e, the nature of proceedings in Motor evidence in stricto sensu is not requ ourt in case of “Chandra @ Chan v & Ors.”, reported as (2022) 1 SCC ome, the minimum wage notification t be absolute one to fix the income of t !$! &#%3-!L#!3-2 ,--2+&-+3-2%&&*$E >-&!*!$-2!-&%,,-!$'*1E 53-%+!*-! *,,.  &-! 
*-!,1*!&*-#3-2*!"# '*!33-&&-.-&*!$'*!3 *,,$&! #! &!1-2> ,--22##&&!*!$-!33-#!  *3, N+!5 ,- -2 %!** *$E! ,--2N+3*-!-2,*2D   
   
   
   
 e claim petition, the claimant/appella e accident and was stated to be workin per month; however, no cogent or support thereof. Nonetheless, it stand ned grievous injuries in the acciden ted for a considerable period, thereb e. In these circumstances, mere absenc to deny just compensation, particular eatment clearly indicate loss of incom otor Accident Claims, being summar t required. In this regard, the Hon’b handa @ Chandraram vs. Mukes SCC 198, held that in the absence o ation can be a yardstick but at the sam e of the deceased and some guesswor 4 -2  -!,1 *!"#&15 !3-2 >**E #! -2 !** ,*2D     ppellant working ent oral ands ccident, thereby absence ticularly income. ummary Hon’ble ukesh sence of he same esswork MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.27 17:01 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment FAO NO.4610 OF 20 is required to be d hereunder:- ?HH 3! *!3- -% $# -3# !-" *!3- 3 45; 9I:   Court in the case (Civil)141 . Relev  1& 3-%  &L# !-* 9;:  33 &1! *!(;;4 **-! ,&!*! #!-&$!*A3 *!3-%-23,  2008 (O&M) to be done to assess the income. Relev HH
!.!3-2,&13&*2* !. 1&*3K.#%*% !3-%-23
!.!3 -%%-#! -2$# -&K*&L#*& # -&K 2-& *!$  *!3-% 3 2&-% &,*1 &,1 . 3# -3#%! &1'*!3-- %- -"#*21-+*-!-2,- *&-2% !3-%&*!-&-!-*3& 3 -  +-  , 45;;;@J+&%-! HHD  2-&%! *-!  '*   &* e case of Jakir Hussein v. Sabir and o . Relevant excerpt is reproduced herein P $ &  +&  %* &*3K !  !- ! .-,# 23 -%+!*-!#! &2##&,--2  $-'&!%!  !-*2*3*-! ,-! L#*&%! &! -%*! -*!3,#*'-223-&-23--2,*'*!$ 33-&*!$,15 K+*!$ *! '*   ;;45! 3-!*&*!$&**!$3- !*!$. 1-! . &%*!*%#% $ 3-&5*-#&%*"#! 3,*%! /5;;;@J>*)) . Relevant excerpt thereof is reproduce &*2*3%*!*%#% $!-*2*3* *%3!!-. !.-,#-! -2*N !3-2-3#%! &1'*!3-!&3- *&-. -! #%*% % -2 3 -#, !- .  - # 3,*%!  & #! ., - +&-# %-! ,1*!3-%-2*'+,5%- -2%*!*%#% $ *,3-%+#*!$ &-&,'*!3-2 *2-2 , *'+,  &!*!$ &-#!  &*& .1 he Hon’ble Suprem nd others reported as 2015(2) R.C. herein below:  %*!*%#% $ !-*2*3*-! * -!,1 23-& - .  K! - &%*!  -2*!3-%*!*%#% $5+& ,-!  %1  *% 2*, - % *! *!. *3L#,*1-2,*2*!3* '*!$*! NP  %*!*%#% $ +&'*,*!$ 3--2,*'*!$! ,*K,*-- $'!2-&#!K*,,,.-#&*! ! ++&-+&*-%-!  ))))@J+&1E 5 roduced *3*-! 2*N &3-& % -,,1 &-#3 - !$ -2   upreme R.C.R -!,1    &   3** !$ *! --2 *! ! ,1 MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.27 17:01 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment FAO NO.4610 OF 20 9:  + ++,,! @3,*% -+*,5 ! * &  &%* &2& &2&& &%*!  %* 33-&*!$,15 I))))@J> 9(:   Ferozepur Jhirka on 22.11.2005, fo   ( ) /  9(: #& *&K> 0J(E53- ,23,'*3,-2 [12.2].  -,,$ !  - *!"#&1! '& &$*-!E3#*!$% [12.3].
!' -!(((;;45* 2008 (O&M) +&#,-2&3-&&', %!   K! - 5 &-A ! *K& !   #.L#! ,1  *!  %* 2&-% (((;;4 && -  *3, -,,$ * 2&-% (/(;;4 - ); ,--2*!3-%#22&.1*% >))))N<E5 *3*&-#! per the testimony of Dr. Santos hirka (PW-6), who had medico legally 05, found following injuries vide MLR  3& -#! -2*A(3% &*$1,*&.,*!$  ,*!$2&-%.-!-&*,  -%+,*! -23+*!'  ,*!$2&-%,2&D #&&5 & 8&*! 8#%&5  53-! #3QJ&1N%*! *-!-2 23,*%!   +&  *3&$ #%%&1 > -+*,5 *+#&  ++,,! @3, '&*!"#&1 *%-&&$*3 $%*,*! *2 '* -22-&**!"#&*! 5*3!&-! .,1. *!2&& *%%*,12&33*!  A+#& *&K5 &2& - 
   *2 - -,!K* -+*,5 , ;4 - ()(;;4 >N ;E  $ !  -+*,5 *+#& & ;(;;4 >N J(;E * < *%#&*!$*+&*-* -22-I)4@J Santosh Jain, Medical Officer in CHC legally examined the appellant/claima e MLR (Ex. PW6/A): 3%NRNR3%-!,&,!$, !$2&-% -#!  +&!  *%-2N%*! *-! '*QJ&1 *3, 22*3&5 5 &-A+ 23,*%! ! 2-#! 2&3#& >N (;E *# .1  * 3,*%!   *$!- * 3 $*33-! #*-!>&*$%+-&-J+&* ! 2333*! -33#&& ++,,! @3,*%! &%*! 6 !   2* , &   &  1  n CHC, laimant $,-2 A+#& #&-2 *3, 3 &*, #&& *!  MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.27 17:01 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment FAO NO.4610 OF 20 . J&*!2-& #&*!$+&*- ₹(/5;;;@J>₹/5;; 9(/: ' ! *K&5  N%*!  .1  %-& - ' #!* 2&3#& - +,3-!&3-& '*!$ &$& - &&*3*-! -! * 2#!3*-! , *. '-3*-!-2 *.*,*1(;G 9(4:  ''& ''& ''& ''& 3,*%! #22& &!--!,1  +&!  3 33*!  /; &*-!3&.&-#$ +&, ,* ?*-! ,
!#& ?*-! ,
!#& ?*-! ,
!#& ?*-! ,
!#& +&!-4I)5  ?4I * 2008 (O&M) &+&*--2.-#*N%-! 5& &*-33-&*!$,15,--2*!3 5;;;SBE '! 2#&&5 & - &&#K   > 0J<E +-  -!  %*3, .-& *3  '& &&*3*-! -2 %-'%!  -2  -2  ,2 3,'*3,  *.*, -&-!*&*!$*.*,*1  -  ! #& -2 -&K +&2-&%  * %-.*,*1 !  &!*!$ 3+3* .*,*1 %1 '&1 2&-% %*3 *!"#&5* -#,. "#!  ;G2-&+#&+--23-%+#*!$2# **-! ,,15-!M.,#+&% &8 &8 &8 &8#%& #%& #%& #%&D&+-&(;(;
 (;(;
 (;(;
 (;(;
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
44)
44)
44)
44),*!3 & *3,33*! 53-%+!*-!%1 .#,-- &2##&+&-+3  3,*%! @++,,!    *% '!3-&&-.-&2&-%3-+1 !-22##&+&-+3*-. -! 3-2-!M.,#+&%-#& *D *D *D *D &+-&  >(;<E B  B >(;<E B  B >(;<E B  B >(;<E B  B *&$&5&#! &6J  !**-!-24;G-23#,,&1 2##&+&-+35 &3 7 3*1  5   # -  %,J  . ! 5!  #,*!$   !  *-! , #- #- #- #- & 1.  
!  -2 +1-2 !  #&*!  B=;  B=;  B=;  B=; ,&1- 3 MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.27 17:01 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment FAO NO.4610 OF 20   4;1 *  9(B:
!' the loss of future prospects @ 30% future prospects b of calculation compensation pay @ Rs.1,87,200/-     9): 
! *.*,*1- -! &3-&  N > 0J<E #&& 0J45 3$-&*3 &%!  -2 * N B5N ()5 &*.#! ,5 #+-! ! 3-%+!*-!#! #! #,1 &&*3*' !  #,1  +&$%*3 ++&- 3,*%! 3!!- &%!  !  2008 (O&M) +&%! ! "-.!  . ,-  **-!-#,. );G5*2$ ;1&
!33 . **-!-#,. 4G3#,,&1 !'* of the above discussion, the future earnings, shall also be entitled t 30%. Therefore, the income of the pects be taken as Rs. 5200/- (4,000 + tion of compensation. Accordingl on payable for the functional disability - (5,200 x 12 x 15 x 20/100).  ?
Q   ?
Q   ?
Q   ?
Q  !  +&!  35  ++,, N! -2(4G5.,*2&- N = !  ,- 2&-% N%*! & %* #*!5 -! -2 3,*% &*3,,1   ++&-N*%,1 * 2&5 !  *! #++-& &-2 ()5N (4-N (<5N );! ! !-*3*!$ 3&*! *3&+!3* * #! &*-₹(;5;;;@J- *'5 +&*3#,&,1 !  23# .,* -! &3-&
 * ,, +&-3 * - .  -+ *, -. N+3-+&&'3  &3-'&1 -!*&*!$  ! $-2/;1&-#,. % $-23 . !/; . !$-24;-B;1&5 &1-#,&3#,,&1,N n, the appellant/claimant in addition titled to compensation for loss of futu of the appellant/claimant after addin 000 + 1,200) per month for the purpos rdingly, this Court finds that th sability to the extent of 20% is assesse @ 

T
 @ 

T
 @ 

T
 @ 

T
 ,,! @3,*%!  #22& +&%! 2&-%*.*,*13&*2*3+&-' ! *-!J*!J3*2 -2 & - &&# ,*%! @++,,!  *, +-*!$ ,1 ₹B;5;;;@J  *!3#&& - & -2 +&-' %*3, .*,, >N  ! N )-N 4)E,&!  *! -% -2  .*,,5 &&*3 - '&5#3&#3*-!++&- 3#% -2 &%!  !  N+! * ,, ,  *! 3 -2 *!"#&1  *!$ %*3, N+!5  ! '&1.*,,#&*!$3-#& ! #& -2 *!"#&*5  &% 8 % /;- &5 ND ition to f future adding purpose at the assessed ! !  &-' &&#K !$  &  - &!    -.  *#& &15     &-2 %!  MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.27 17:01 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment FAO NO.4610 OF 20 #! &K!5 ! 3-%+!*-! -2₹B;5;;;@J*         9/:  -& &2&!3 %1 . #&,*&' #&,*&' #&,*&' #&,*&'   & -2 3- 3-%%!#& #&*-! -2 -+ 3,*%! ,' ?4  U 22,* &+&- "#* #22 ++ ;5; %- 94: 
! #+&%-#&* 23 !  3*&3#% -3#%! &1 ' *!"#&**!3,#*! !   '&  &$*-!E 3#*!$ 2008 (O&M) !   ,*K,*-- -2 *!3*!  &.1&*.#! , &&!  ,-. "#! &-! .,#!   
 
   
 
   
 
   
 
 -&*!$"#3-%+!*-!#! 1 .  & ! -  3**-! -2  #..#,K%* #..#,K%* #..#,K%* #..#,K%*!&5(;(/
 !&5(;(/
 !&5(;(/
 !&5(;(/
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
==B5 /
==B5 /
==B5 /
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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment FAO NO.4610 OF 20 -,,$ !  - #&$-!55 >N J=E+& *.*,*1#5 -#, 3-!*# #22&*!$     9B: 
! 3,*%! @++,, ++&-N*%,1E 3,*%!  -#, 3-!'1!35 ! & "# ! 3-%+!*-! # 3-!-,*#%   
   
   
   
 9<: 
! ++,,! @3,*% %!! &6J - - - -      - 5= (  ) -% 2008 (O&M) -+*, *+#&E '! 2#&&5 5! *K&5 > 0J<E+&-' & *3++,,! @3,*%!  2 #5*!#%.,-+*!*-!-2* # "# !  &-! ., 3-%+!   U  
   U  
   U  
   U  
 !+&! 353-!*&*!$ ,,! 5  +&*- -2 *%%-.*,* E !   &L#*&%!  -2 +-J-+ , ' *!3#&& #.! *, N !  ! !  3&$ - '&5 !  &-! ., 3-%+!*-! #  #! &  2-&*  * #%-2₹5;;5;;;@J   ! '*  -2   . ! %! ,,. ! *,2-&$&! #& #& #& #& - -2
!3-% >I)4V  (/5 5=<5(;;E *3,N+!@-+*,*A*-! -%+!*-!#! &-&+3#!*&1 5 & - &&#K5 &-+ &-'-!&3-&*.*,*13&*2*3 2-#! -. '*!$(4G+&%! -#&5!%-#! -2/5;;5;; !*-! #! &   -2 +*! M M M M ! #&-2*!"#&*#22&.1 .*,*A*-!@. J& >* B %-! -+&*' 3&5* * '*!   N+! *#& - & +3*, * &5  ,&!  &*.#! ,  2*,  #! &   33-&*!$ * & !  !!3 - ! *3# &*! .-'5 ! -23-%+!*-!*!2-,,- * %-#! >*!E %-#! >*!E %-#! >*!E %-#! >*!E (/5;;; V  (5(5)4@J B;5;;;@J &1 5;;5;;;@J 10 *3 2*3 ! !  5;;;@J  !  1 -!    *5  - *!$,15 -   *!$ MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.27 17:01 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment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
!#&!3-%+!1 *-! ,
!#&!3-%+!1 *-! ,
!#&!3-%+!1 *-! ,
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
!3 %,,. +1.,&2  +&*- -2 & %-!  2&-% - 2 3-%+!*-! ,&1 +* - 3-%+!*-!  *!!3 -2 ++,,! @3,*%!  -2   & + .1  ,&! ,,&%*!%&%*!  !>E*2!15,,,-! *+- >8 E >8 E >8 E >8 E          11 #*! * * * * >(;;IE >(;;IE >(;;IE >(;;IE -& -& -& -& & -   2& -1 -  !  * &!  .1 +- MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.27 17:01 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment