RFA Nos.316 & 563



                                                                                              !""#$ !   %&!$     !       01  ,2 ))"(* (!" + (367,,$,&#89(! +!":,$-%(3$(!" 01  - 2($"2<=>>? $&+"!"%"!!"2( 0B1  !, ,$7($"29,$',#$ 3(4" $& +" (367 of 1999 (O&M)  
    
    
    
    
 
 
 
    & & & &BBBB    ($"&%" ($"&%" ($"&%" ($"&%"            


 


 


 


        
 
 
 
    & & & &DDDD             


 


 


 


  
  
  
  
   
   
   
   
    !"")(;&#(;2:&3($" &!$'"())"**(#$ !+',#('(,#(!-(# EEEE  . !(*/  . !(*/  . !(*/  . !(*/ ,2" $', 3&44&# &!2"!  +&$' $  +",#5 2"3,2"2 ( $'" (4" 9(!2,#:&*:,#5,2"#$,3(*%(3$(#2 (!"+",#5$(;"#%!&4&BC - 9(- &% )!""#$ ())"(*./ 3'(** >>?)("2+-$'"*"(!#"222* ($'"@"%"!"#3"&7!$A/ !,"%*- $($,#5 ,# $'" )!""#$ 3( $'"!":"#7""$($"&%:,**(5"&' 367,!"2 :,2" &$,%,3($,&# 2($"2         BC BC BC BC&% &% &% &%>> >> >> >>>>>>. F/ . F/ . F/ . F/ "3,,&# "3,,&# "3,,&# "3,,&#   <<<<BBBB< < < <CCCC      ))"**(#$ ))"**(#$ ))"**(#$ ))"**(#$   
   
   
   
     ")&#2"#$ ")&#2"#$ ")&#2"#$ ")&#2"#$....//// DCB DCB DCB DCB&% &% &% &%>>> >>> >>> >>>. F/ . F/ . F/ . F/      ))"**(#$ ))"**(#$ ))"**(#$ ))"**(#$   
   
   
   
     ")&#2"#$ ")&#2"#$ ")&#2"#$ ")&#2"#$....////         (#(  $'" (%&!"4"#$,&#"2 "57*(! , " '(:" (!,"# &7$ &% 3&44 #267"$,&#&%*(9&!$'"(;" &%>>> (**"#5" '( +""# *(,2 $& $'" 9( *,$!,3$725"(,$'(*.'"!",#(% 3("./ *(#2 4"(7!,#5 > (3 &'"!,(#"',*(#2,$!,3$(,$' 2 <=>>B (#2 <<>> ,7 1 ,!$ 4&# ;"&% 9(!2 (%$"! (3!" ,$'(* 7"2 MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.13 15:51 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA Nos.316 & 563 7#2"!"3$,&# !")"3$,:"*-%&! ,#&! %!&4  &B 7#2"! "3 &**"3$&! .%&!  (367,!"2*(#29 +"#"%,$(#2,#$" 01  , ())"**(#$8*(#2&9 3(4" $& +" 2, <=>>?$'"! 3&)" %&! %7!$'" 55!,":"2 $'"!" *(#2&9#"! 0D1 
 '( )()"!+&&;(9 7+4,,&#4(2 0C1   ) )!&273"23"!$,%," $&9(!2"#'(#3" $'")"!,&2)&$# 3("./$'73(# 7+$(#$,($" (#- (367,!"2*(#2 of 1999 (O&M)  FC&%$'"(#2367,,$,&# &!$'")7+*,3)7!)&"#(4"*-@%&!  < $& B=D< &%% $(;,#5 %!&4 "3$,&#  &% $'" ?> 3$ 9( ! '&!$ @$'" A/ &# B<C>> 9((""2HC<<<<8I)"! #$"!"$)!&:,2"27#2"!$'"?> ,($,%,"2 9,$' $'" 9(!2 2&9#"!,#:&;"2"%"!"#3"7#2"! 2,)&"2 &% +- $'" *"(!#"2 "% "!"+-7)'&*2,#5$'"4(!;"$:(*7" $'"! "#'(#3"4"#$ &% $'" (,2 4( "!"&% $'" )!""#$ ())"(* 9"!  '(:" '"(!2 *"(!#"2 3&7#"* %&! 9"**(!"3&!2&%$'"3("./
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
(47#(+*"$&%,#27+$(#3",#$ *(#2&9#"!  9 $'($ $'" ())"**(#$8*(#2&9# B$&G ID,#7))&!$&%$'",!3*( (**$'"(,2(*"2""2)"!$(,#"2 $,&#&%$'"?>3$,#$'")!"" ,$#&&$'"!":,2"#3"'(+""#*"2 &$"#$,(* (2:(#$(5" ($$(3'"2 $& $ 2 3$A/ "!'"!, 9(!2 ,$,&# % $'" $7$&!- $'" ',3' 2($"2 #5#& *(#2 " &% ' $'" ,#$'" #"! 3*(,4 "2$& ""#$ *"2$& & $'" MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.13 15:51 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA Nos.316 & 563 0=1 
#  (""2+-$'" &9":"!3&#,2 3(!!,"2&7$ %&! $ ,#&!%!&4 !"7*$"2 ,#$& +,% "#$,$*"2%&!2(4( $'" !")&#2"#$ &9#"2+-$'"() $'" &$'"! ,2" & +&7#2 $& 7%%" ,#3&#:"#,"#3"$& &!"&:"! ":"! (*$"!3($,&# ,# (3 :,(+,*,$-'7$ (!"5(!2":"!( 0?1   3("./ $'" (9( %&**&9,#5"%%"3$ .,/  +"# !"(2 of 1999 (O&M)  # 73' 3,!374$(#3" $'" 2"$"!4 '":,2",$9(!22($"2B ,2"!,#5$'"%(3$$'($$'"(367,,$, ! $'")7+*,3)7!)&" #(4"*-%&! <$&B=D<&%%$(;,#5%!&4 +,%7!3($,&# &% *(#2 &9#"2 +- $' 4(5"&#(33&7#$&%":"!(#3"&% $ $'($ ( ( !"7*$ &% $'" )!""#$ ())"**(#$8*(#2&9#"!$&&2+,%7 " &% 4,#&!
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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA Nos.316 & 563 .,,/ 4(! 3&# %!&4 0>1  33 $"!4 0<1  "#    (!3' (!3' (!3' (!3'   < < < <C C C C $,; J'" J'" of 1999 (O&M)  ,,/ *(#2&9#"!8())"**(#$ '(** (!;"$ :(*7" (5(,#$ ":"!(#3" &#$!73$,&#&%'7#2'"!'"!,4,#& !&4D>D<,!(!(#3' 33&!2,#5*- +&$' $'" ())"(* $( "#2,#5())*,3($,&#./,%(#-'(**(     . . . .       '"$'"!)"(;,#58!"(&#"2 "8 '"$'"!!")&!$(+*"  "8 ** (*& +" "#$,$*"2 %&! <K &% 3" &% $'",! *(#2 &# (33&7#$ ,#&!%!&4<$&B=D<&%%$(;, $(#2 2,)&"2 &% ,# $'" (%&!"( **(*&$(#22,)&"2&%  /  /  /  /         "8& "8& 4  $'" $ &% (;,#5 "(,2 MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.13 15:51 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment