Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

1996 DAILYLAW 8 (PNJ)

(O&M) GEETA DEVI (DECEASED) THROUGH ITS LRS AND OTHERS v. HARYANA STATE ELECTRICITY BOARD & ANOTHER

RFA/1460/1996 · 2026-02-02

Harkesh Manuja

body1996

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

RFA No.1460 of 1996                                                     !""#$ !   .,!$    !      .,!$    !          45  6 8899:0%" 3"!"."!!"*%$/" 485  !( %!'%) ($2%$"* "/(' /%#"%! *%$"* 8899 ->2(($(,#-$) #%&"'6 .,! -,# '"-$!(-($6,%!* %#* ->2(($(, 996 (O&M)                        , , , ,    %$",." %$",." %$",." %$",."                                ))))                      !  %&'()*+,-%$" ,!$/"%00"''%#$ !  %(#()*+,-%$"1($/ 2!3/( %#%)*+,-%$" ,!$/"!"0,#*"#$, ! 3/(#%/%(#))%!6%# AAAA  ) !%'  ) !%'  ) !%'  ) !%' 61%6,.0!""#$%00"%')-/%''"#7" "*36$/"'"%!#"***'($!(-$ $/"; "."!"#-",2!$< !(".'6 $%$(#7) (# $/" 0!""#$ -% "* 1($/(# $/" !"+"#2" "$%$" ,. + %!) ($!(-$ 2!2=/"$!%) -%&" $ 998 %#* BC998 (2"* 2#* -$)9?.,!/,!$$/";9?-$< ,#$!2-$(,# ,. B8  23 $% %!*#1%!*2#*"!"-$(,#, ($(,# ,''"-$,! .,! /,!$ ;$/"                 ,?:,.99: @ ,?:,.99: @ ,?:,.99: @ ,?:,.99: @ "-((,# "-((,# "-((,# "-((,#8 8 8 8888888 88 88 88::::                   00"''%#$ 00"''%#$ 00"''%#$ 00"''%#$ )   )   )   )  @   @   @   @    "0,#*"#$ "0,#*"#$ "0,#*"#$ "0,#*"#$         %#%  #7"/%3""#'%(*$,$/"1%!**%$ (-$2*7") 2!2=/"$!%/"!"(#%.$"! -%") '%#* &"%2!(#7 D %#%' . +(''%7" (! (0'() %*3%$ ,BD " $, 3" %->2(!"* +(*" ,$(.(-%$(, #*"! "-$(,# ? @ : ,. $/" % <!"0"-$(+"'6.,!$/"023'(-02!0, $%$(,#) (0'( ,. $/" %!6%#% $ ,.$/"9?-$1%0%"*36$ " < ,# BB99?) $/"!" 1     *%$"* $"!$, ' 9 BD9) $(,# %#* !0," $%$" 6$/" "!"36 MOHMED ATIK 2026.02.10 18:35 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA No.1460 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA No.1460 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA No.1460 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA No.1460 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA No.1460 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA No.1460 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA No.1460 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment