Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

1995 DAILYLAW 45 (PNJ)

GIRDHARA SINGH v. STATE OF PUNJAB

RFA/2351/1995 · 2026-02-02

Harkesh Manuja

body1995

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

RFA No.2351 of 1995                                                          "##$% "   "     "  !  !  !  ! (334 (334 (334 (3345555( ( ( (   "&7 9#./%+'# $,+$ "#*($)#$%(<   (%   #& 8&)#+$%-#*"#   *( 8#$%+($#)+$%-#   8 (<=>(6 (<=>(6 (<=>(6 (<=>(6 ?@  7 )&%#) B>44 -#"#+$&6%#"%(2# 995 (O&M)                        ( ( ( (<<<<    &%#(6# &%#(6# &%#(6# &%#(6#                              !     !     !     ! ""$&'(())'(.&%#A+%- "&$*"##%+$,-)'(.&%#6("% "/$0&$#-%&))1 /$ EEEE   "&1   "&1   "&1   "&1 (6 (6 (6 (6<<> <<> <<> <<> "&7#" 8&)# +$ %-# &**1+.&%+($ + ,+$##" "('+$.+&1 +'++($ : <+$*1&.#(69#./%+'#$,+$##" (%+.#(6%-#&**1+.&%+($ #&"$#)%&%#.(/$#1&..#*%$(%+. "##$%&**1+.&%+($ *($ -#&"+$, 1#&"$#) .(/$#1 6(" %-#&**1+.&%+($%-#&8#+&11(A#) 8#$)#)8#8((6*&"%+#2#%&F#$ (644> ; (644> ; (644> ; (644> ; 7 A&7 (6 *"##$% &**#&1 .-&11 44> *&#) 27 %-# 1#&"$#)  2#"#6#""#)&%-#C #6#"#$.#(/                 <=> <=> <=> <=>(6 (6 (6 (644> 44> 44> 44> ;  ;  ;  ; #.++($ #.++($ #.++($ #.++($< < < << < < <<< << << <<GGGG            **#11&$% **#11&$% **#11&$% **#11&$%                    #*($)#$%  #*($)#$%  #*($)#$%  #*($)#$%         "%-#&**#11&$%H1&$)(A$#" /$0&2   + 6(" +8*1#&)+$, %-# &**1+.&$% : ;  "&$.- (-+&"*/" #"; (-+&"*/" (%+.#&$))(#$(%(**(#%-#*"&7 6(" %-# *&"%+# &$) 6(" %-# "#&( #)/20#.%%(&110/%#9.#*%+($ #$($"#.(") &11#$,# -& 2##$ 1&+) %( %-# A& ))1 +%"+.% /),# (-+&"* (/"%D 1 &$% /" & "&7#" &($  A&") &"*/" MOHMED ATIK 2026.02.04 14:29 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA No.2351 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA No.2351 of 1995 ?@  /"% (/"% -& &# &.I/+"#)1&$)+$ "#.(")27-& & :5<%-#&* %&$)+$,('#"%-# & *#" "#*("% 9 *"#*&"#) 27 " /$0&2 -&$)+, *"#*&"#) +$ &7 A#"# +$+%+&%#) .(8*#$&%+($- %(4B4& *"+.#+$)#9*"#'& ?B@  -# *"+.#+$)#9,+'# )#.++($ )&%#)  +$,- &$) !&"$ +$,- &$) !&"$ +$,- &$) !&"$ +$,- &$) !&"$ /..#(" +$ +$%# /..#(" +$ +$%# /..#(" +$ +$%# /..#(" +$ +$%# #-+1 &%-&$F( #-+1 &%-&$F( #-+1 &%-&$F( #-+1 &%-&$F( #1#'&$%*&"&%-# K-# A-+. #9*" 8&) 6("% +$ 995 (O&M) /"%-#" %&F+$, +$%( %-# &..(/$% %- ##) %-# 8&"F#% '&1/# A+%- "#* +$%#"8(6"#*("%)&%#)>4 &A+$)#"+$,-("%+./1%/"## &**#11&$%H1&$)(A$#"+-#1)#$%+%1# %-#&.I/+"#)1&$)27%&F+$,+$%(&.  9 5> -(A#'#" %-# #'&1/&%+($ " +00#" +"#.%(" (6 ("%+./1% )+,&"- /"%-#" .($+)#"+$, %-# 6 &7 4B> A-#"#& %-# &.I/++%+( ) '+)# $(%+6+.&%+($ )&%#)  -(/1)2#.&""+#)(/%27,+'+$,&* &6%#"&**17+$,%-#)+66#"#$.#(6 #'&+1+$,&%%-#"#1#'&$%*(+$%+$%+8 -#&6("#8#$%+($#)6("8/1&(6+$. +'#$+$6&'(/"(61&$)(A$#"A& ) <B<< *&#) +$  (  (  (  ( &"$&+1 +$,- ($ (6 -"+ !#&" &"$&+1 +$,- ($ (6 -"+ !#&" &"$&+1 +$,- ($ (6 -"+ !#&" &"$&+1 +$,- ($ (6 -"+ !#&"  +$%#"#% (6 1&%# -"+ !#&" 2(%-  +$%#"#% (6 1&%# -"+ !#&" 2(%-  +$%#"#% (6 1&%# -"+ !#&" 2(%-  +$%#"#% (6 1&%# -"+ !#&" 2(%- $F(%  / $F(%  / $F(%  / $F(%  /$0&2 %&%# %-"(/,-  $0&2 %&%# %-"(/,-  $0&2 %&%# %-"(/,-  $0&2 %&%# %-"(/,-  %-#"#(6+"#*"()/.#)-#"#/$)#"5 -# &**#&1 + 6(" #$-&$.#8#$% (6 . -+.- A#"# 1(% %( %-# (A$#" 27 %-# 9*"##)+%-&%%-# #6#"#$.#(/"%- &)#&*#"%-#6("8/1&.&11#) " ("%-#7#&"4B>-#1#&"$#).(/$# $ /$0&2 8&11 $)/%"+# &$) 9*(  %-# 6&.% %-&% %-# 1#&"$#) #6#"#$ *#.% %( %-# %"## %&$)+$, ('#" % 44=9 5>A-+.-A&*"('#) #'#1(*8#$% 66+.#"A-(&**#&" +%1#)6("%-#8&"F#%'&1/#(6%-#%"# &..(/$%%-#$/82#"(6%"##&$)& $ 2# )($# +$ %#"8 (6 %-# 6("8/ /1%/"# #*&"%8#$% ('#"$8#$% # 6&.% %-&% " +00#"D 6("8/1& A %+($ *"(.##)+$, +$ %-# *"##$% .& 4B4 %-/ %-# &#8#$% &**"(*"+&%#+$."#&#6"(8&74 (6%-#*#".#$%&,#(6&**"#.+&%+($ %+8# +$."#&#2&#)($%-#&**1+.&%+($ &#'#$&**"('#)27%-+(/"%'+ (=3B (6 44< (=3B (6 44< (=3B (6 44< (=3B (6 44< +$ .&# (6 K!&" K!&" K!&" K!&" &" +$,- ($ (6 -"+ !#&" +$ &" +$,- ($ (6 -"+ !#&" +$ &" +$,- ($ (6 -"+ !#&" +$ &" +$,- ($ (6 -"+ !#&" +$ (%- "#+)#$% (6 +11&,# &")(&"& (%- "#+)#$% (6 +11&,# &")(&"& (%- "#+)#$% (6 +11&,# &")(&"& (%- "#+)#$% (6 +11&,# &")(&"& - (11#.%(" /")&*/" &$) %-#" - (11#.%(" /")&*/" &$) %-#" - (11#.%(" /")&*/" &$) %-#" - (11#.%(" /")&*/" &$) %-#"  (6 .(8*#$&%+($ 6(" '&1/# (6 %-# %"#  %-# &.I/++%+($ (6 1&$) -# ,"+#'&$ "%-&)&..#*%#)%-#'&1/&%+($(6%-#%"# +00&" 6("8/1& 6("&#+$,%-#%"# $#16("%-#&**#11&$%A(/1)&",/#%- 9*("% ("*("&%+($ +8+%#) #"/ L 3 "#$.# " %-# #)($ #&"#) %"## &,# "8/1& $% (6 A&  .&# $% (6 4B> ($(6 ($(6 '+)# !&"%&" !&"%&" !&"%&" !&"%&" +$,- +$,- +$,- +$,- &"&$ &"&$ &"&$ &"&$ %-#"M %-#"M %-#"M %-#"M # %"## #'&$.# #%"## #%"## /#%-&%  L&+1 MOHMED ATIK 2026.02.04 14:29 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA No.2351 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment