Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
1952 DAILYLAW 5 (PNJ)
THE NEW INDIA INSURANCE CO LTD v. GOBIND RAM & ORS
XOBJC/264/2016 · 2026-04-08
Sudeepti Sharma
body1952
[ 1952 DAILYLAW 5 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 1952 DAILYLAW 5 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
FAO-1952-2015 (O&M) & XOBJC-264-CII-2016 1 FAO-1952-2015 (O&M) & X-OBJC-264-CII-2016 ! "#$
%&'# ( ! )*" + !
, -., / //
/ , !"
# $ # %
&
# $ " ! ' !# $ %
&(
)
*** +,-(./01&.2*/3 "4
# $ %
*. && /
/ ,0 1+2 123 4,5 * 5
%
6
*728.2*0
5
#'
! +%
#9 5
:3 %
"*//)*02)*0*%
# *;77# 6
)
6 ) GAURAV ARORA 2026.04.09 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-1952-2015 (O&M) & XOBJC-264-CII-2016 2 + 3 % 8#<=#0<7)& 6
><=?
6 ! 1! . 5
&( $
%
&(
)6
% & +
***
3 6 18.03.2014 passed by the learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Kurukshetra %
"*//)*02)*0*%
#*;77# %
% #6
+ 3 % 8#<=#0<7)& 6
> <=?
%(
%%
8
" %
& ( %
&(
)6
%
6 %
*728.2*0
5
#
%
# 1+2 12 6 !
1!
$ ( 6 0 -;0.2*8# 66
;22#
%"
&
# #
*.&
"6
$6
6 6
@&2<@&;.*;+
&& %
%
9%%6$ %
$3#
66 $
6 # %
6
A # %
$(
6%
%% A % 6 #
*% A B6 # % 6"
GAURAV ARORA 2026.04.09 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-1952-2015 (O&M) & XOBJC-264-CII-2016 3 %
%%%
.<; 887% #*7/2
6
6
*.# % 6
%
6
# '
!
*. *8 = C % #
% % / D
6 %
# %6
%
5
&
! " #$ % &# $$ '
(
) ' *+
, ) '
-
,) '
&
./*$0.*!# !
& 1& / -- # + , ' 2 ' & '-- % ' & 3 & -/*% " / 4 8#<=#0<7)& ! " # $ %& ' ( & ' GAURAV ARORA 2026.04.09 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-1952-2015 (O&M) & XOBJC-264-CII-2016 4 / ,// / . /./ / 7 % & 5 ! % D 6 % % % % % %6D@% %%6$ E D( @# % # ; # % ***) & ( 5 6 & & + 3@% 5 $ 5 % # &( % & % *2 $ %
% ** 4% 6% # $ % & 5+ 6 $ 6 , ' ! " #$ %
1&
/ &
& 7
,
2
8 -* ,'' '
GAURAV ARORA 2026.04.09 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-1952-2015 (O&M) & XOBJC-264-CII-2016 5
&
& 7
0%33
-, !0%2 -9,
2 -0
,
:2 -;
*2 -!
& 3 3 & & +' & < ,1& / , , & / ' 7 < ' -* 8 ' & ' -* ' 7 ' & +' 1 ) / , !!%=#>7 - & ) / * =-?.>* $! & , * & # 7 ' @ )/ -* ' ' , ' < 0% 33 -, !0%2 -9, # " #$ % ' & 1& / < GAURAV ARORA 2026.04.09 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-1952-2015 (O&M) & XOBJC-264-CII-2016 6 . ,8 ' 1& / ' % " #$ % 2 -9 ' ' & ' % " #$ % + 7 & , ' ' & # " #$ %, 2 ' A,' 7 ' -* 2 *2 %
+ , 7 & 7 & & ' & ,' 1& / %3 , *. % % F % 6 $ 5 # $ % $ $ # 6 6 %6 E % 66 $6% %%6$ *. *8 5 % G&* B6 ' # & # 6% $ $ @ E $ % 66 $6% & $ 6 ( $ 6 & GAURAV ARORA 2026.04.09 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-1952-2015 (O&M) & XOBJC-264-CII-2016 7 F # 6 $ @ # % # # 6# # 6 5 *0 5 % % 1 6 6 66 %
D E % %%6$ $% 5 66 D % F # $% % ( % ! 66 # $6 % !
*= 6 # 6 % D % # F 5 E 6 & */ $% $# % $ #6 # % %6 5 5 $ %$ % # # % # % *< $ 6 &( % 6 % ) &( !6 % # % !6 /..7 , / *7 @: " 6 6 6 % 5 F % "8 GAURAV ARORA 2026.04.09 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-1952-2015 (O&M) & XOBJC-264-CII-2016 8 9%'":8";9%'""#<3 1151/%)'%#"= =# & B 7 AC <, !;;=D<D> ' & , ' ,2 & , 7& ' ' , , & & 7 & & 2 ,' & , & < & ,& ' 7 & & ,
& ' ' & , & = 3 8 & + 7 8 ,<+/ !0$ 3%09,/ ( .
-3 =+
>) , !!B= > 33BB E
& , !0$<3
"90> 9 7 '
'
'
F !
"# = > 2 , : , , , , 2 = >) = >' ' & , F = >) G =&> ) & = >@ 2 * =1 ( > = >( , =>) = H > = >)2 = > + , ' & ' = >,= >= > = > + , ' & , ' & = >=&>,= >,=> = > & , 2 , = H > 2 222 222 222 222 $%&' ( ) *+, GAURAV ARORA 2026.04.09 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-1952-2015 (O&M) & XOBJC-264-CII-2016 9 = >< = & >, = >7 & ' ' & , & & 7 , & =2 ' ,'7 & & , & > = >7' * '2 & 2 &
2 & 7 ' & & 7 & ' = > 7 & , , &, , -.& )/// 0 *( ()/)/( 11F7 , ' ,' %$ / %$$$H* < (D , & & ' 9$I & ' %$I 7 ' & 7 & BI & , & ,& ' 3 ' & 'F >< & F/ %9,$$$H* &>) = BI >F / B"$$H* >A & ' F 0 >) F=B"$$2 0>F / ! ,;$$H* 11F7
'
%$ ,
/ %$$$H* .
&
9$I .'
&
.
,;$$H* 11F7
'
%$ ,
/ %$$$H* .
&
9$I .'
&
. ' & &, ' & 77 & 0BI 3 ' & 'F >< F/ %9,$$$H* &>) =0BI > F/ #0$$$H* >A & ' F 0 >) F=#0$$$2 0>F/ ",B!,$$$H* GAURAV ARORA 2026.04.09 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-1952-2015 (O&M) & XOBJC-264-CII-2016 10 11 F 7 ' #B < ,' ', ' ' 7 & ' 0$I < ' , ' 0$I 7 ' & 'F >A ' & F/ 9$,$$$H* &>) =0$I2 > F/ "#$$$H* >A & =#B > F ; >) F="#$$$2 ;> F/ 0,B9,$$$H* J F 7 =<> =E> 7 + =3>' & < 8 A = >K *; @: " % 2 3 &4& )5 &>3 1 51!/!( ? % " *//#*/8& */7% #*;77# %6 & + 3 % $6 F A +43 "% 6 6% A +3 6% % 6 A + 3 %6
$ # # % # % % F # A +H3 D % 6 % % %% 6 (A %& %F 5 $ % ( 6 & I 7,' 2 & + & , , , 2 & / B,$$$, / "$,$$$ / B,$$$ 7 & E & * * ' & ' & & & $I & ' & 4 GAURAV ARORA 2026.04.09 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-1952-2015 (O&M) & XOBJC-264-CII-2016 11 .2 @:" % ) 4& 0 &&3 &-.-.6-$7%8 & 50 7 ' &2 & F !#)/ /1$91 /1$:1G 7 & #% + 3 ) - ,#$ 0<3L #0$$= 3> + "9 ,3 E & &
C = > ( 7 3 <,#$$!<3L #!;= 3> + B*#B , &D ;D ' 2 & 7 & 3 ,,' & &D ;D D 0D !*#3/ /)() * /;$&$< + , ' & L A ?,#$ ;<3L $ = 3> 8 < ( ?<,#$ 0<3L!0!= 3> 2 & ' L = > ;F M; + & && < ' & & ' 7 ' , ' F = > - , G = > ) G = > 7 & ' G = > A 2 & G => )2 M J K 7
& : , 8 = > ' ' & & + , '2 & , ' H : ; & N < GAURAV ARORA 2026.04.09 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-1952-2015 (O&M) & XOBJC-264-CII-2016 12 #$ L #$ % 7 & F M2 / F = > = > && = > && = > %,"?B => & = > = > && 2 ' , & 3 ' E , ' 2 @, & % 8 = > ' , & ,, ' '
& & % I 7 & + 3 ) = >, 9 = >, ,' &B$I !# )) )) $-< + , ' ' !I ' L O = > , ,' & ' !I ' & 3 23= 2 ; 7 , & , B ,' & 'F ( ) ' =/ ",9";2 #2% H $$ / !,; ,!0;H* @ =B$ / ",!$,!;!H* GAURAV ARORA 2026.04.09 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-1952-2015 (O&M) & XOBJC-264-CII-2016 13 > A 2 , , / ;,"9,;9"H* ) / B,$$,$$$H* ) , / ,B$,$$$H* - / #,$$,$$$H* 7 / " ,9!,;% H* 7 ' ,,& / " ,9!,;% H* '
!I .* % 6 $ + 3 =7 % 6 # 5 6 %; .. % 6 % $ !6 5 5 6 6 % $ " %@ % //==)& 5 % # % 6 .8 % % $ 5 6 *=?
%
% + 3
#1 @ %
.0
%
%
5
+ 3
% %%
6#
E
GAURAV ARORA 2026.04.09 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-1952-2015 (O&M) & XOBJC-264-CII-2016 14 .=
%%
$
6$ % #
&E % %
$D
# $
%
$ 6
$%
% 6
$% ! %%
%6
% % %%
6
$ (
(
# %%
%
%%%
!D
G&8
4
#
6
6 % + 3 6 %%
82? 6
%
6%82?5 %
% + 3 %%
% 6 E ./ 5 @: F
%J> ?
)+ ** @) ) -.-A 2 ::B 6 6 6 $ 6 E % %% 65 $ % & I B 8 ' &* , ,P D , * & * , ( &,' * & , ' / B,$$,$$$H* P D, * GAURAV ARORA 2026.04.09 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-1952-2015 (O&M) & XOBJC-264-CII-2016 15 ' & / $,$$,$$$H*,' &, & ' K .< 5 % # $ % $ ( 6 % % # 6 %2*"A< % %% 6 .7 % % $ % %6 (# % # % %% 6 % 6 $$ % .; 5 6 $ @:" ")C") !" #+&2>)8-.-7 2 $$995 F $ F L % L F % # %% 6 ( $ $$% % $6 $ # $
# $6 6 %% ( #% % % ( &$ E # % ( # 6 6 $ $ % 82 5 $ F % % ( 6 5 # 7 ' 7 & & .
3
' / B,B#,$!BH* ,
,
,
2 ,
, 2 '
&
, GAURAV ARORA 2026.04.09 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-1952-2015 (O&M) & XOBJC-264-CII-2016 16
,
7 &
*
4 8*
%
%
$ 6 6
6 # % %%5
%
#
E
6%
3 8. $% $# %
B'B 6$%
#
&( %
&(
)
***+6
% & 3
"**C 5
*728.2*0 %
6 5
& (
)
***+6
% & 3
&
&
&2& (
+ / 9,9BBH* # ) = $I> / 99BH* = $I/ 99BBH*> % < + / ;0;"$H* =/ 0%#$H*Q #>
" )
%$I
&
/ #9,%B#H* =/ ;0;"$Q%$I> B A
! / #,%0, 9;H* =/ #9,%B#H*Q!> 9 -
/ B,$$,$$$H* 0 < 3 / B$,$$$H* ; 7
3 / B$,$$$H* !
(
/ B$,$$$H* $ ( ,D &:8:98$B:ED
" ,D < ' & 7
& &;8978A9:ED ) / &78$$8B%.ED !:8:98$B:D;8978A9:# GAURAV ARORA 2026.04.09 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-1952-2015 (O&M) & XOBJC-264-CII-2016 17 88
"%
# @:"
" )C") 4& ) )4 -.$%6 ;$9B &4 )4 & 2 !-.--#7 $.9#
> ;?
%
%%6% # % M 80
&
6
5
% %
%
%% ( 65
5
% 6
6
% &
*** 8= 6 + 3#% # % 3/
/ ,5 08.04.2026
$ G
!6)& !6 B ) G
B GAURAV ARORA 2026.04.09 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document