RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH (102) RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) Reserved on: 18.03.2026 Pronounced on:30.03.2026 Uploaded on: 02.04.2026 CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIRINDER AGGARWAL !"#$%& '"$% ( )"$%( "$% (*+ ,,,,, VIRINDER AGGARWAL, J - ( . (($ % / "--01-223 4 5 & ( 6( & & &6 / " -+07-212 5 ( ((& Background Facts * 6(($ $" " 8($((( & ( ( /9(" ( POONAM 2026.04.02 02:43 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 2 (-((&(" :&( #"& ('*7& $%$ ( ((; < ( ( "/ (*=(" ("(((((8 (& > :& (""" (" ("! Uttam Singh (common ancestor) ↓ Ram Singh ↓ Piara Singh (defendant No.1) ↓ Avtar Singh (defendant No.8) ↓ Makhan Singh (plaintiff) ? (( $&(($ $< ? ( ($ (( " & & " ('-$ )$ "& (( $($& :&( (( $ $ $ $ POONAM 2026.04.02 02:43 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 3 </" + @$& ($&(/ &" " &%/:&$ $ % 9& " #$&( & ""& ( ( &?"$&('- &( "8" $ (%(('*7&%$($ (( & (( ( : & ( & "&"(( /$" % $ (((($ " ('-$ &"9 5? ( /$& &" 6 "(& (% / ( ( (( ($% ( "8($&%"% (((/ "? $"( & ( 3 ?( ($5 ("(& *+*-217!6 POONAM 2026.04.02 02:43 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 4 ! ! "! # # $ % !& '$ ( )* ($" 5 ("(& 71-21=!6 + ! & # # $ 75$"( &" % $ &6( ?:'--$ 5 /9 (" (('- )$ % 9&$ "((% " A-B)A*4 & /$" ($(" 6 (@" $ POONAM 2026.04.02 02:43 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 5 #" C86-*6-75( (% "& ( &$ & %% "&$&/66"(( < D ! "#$% +(9 $-237$5"%&9& &$ =5:'*( C8 6- E 6*&8 A3 " 68" % &" ( & (" F A (( (% (< $ %6 ((;& &/(" &&(%((( ( 1 % / " 5$ ((( # $ #45%( (5 " & 4 $ #(( (# & % " 9 &$% "& $('- POONAM 2026.04.02 02:43 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 6 " 5% -2=> "" / 5" & 5 %((& ( % $5& %/:% %"*10=-2236(( / " &( ((;(% ( '16&&% % " C8 - * 9; 9 5-217 % G8%H$4 5(($ "(( 6 ""& & ' &()*++ , -&. / &(+*+ &0 & /& && 1 &)..! + 5(%((;"( A3"&( ? $45 ((&" && 2 "( # $ 6(((@"$& $(& &$ $ CONTENTIONS POONAM 2026.04.02 02:43 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 7 -0(.((%" / "--01-223 4 5(((" %(&($%$ (9&$&( :& 45 ""(""% &6( ( 5 & " && $ ((:&"( " ((9$-237$ %& (% (((+($" &%(%((" % $ $/(" ( $ #(# $ % 9&("%& 9&& % $" " % & < $ $ $ % % (" (" ( % & A*$ A> A3 % & % ( " (&$&" ($& <(% "( 5 %4I/ "(9;5 ! "&%$(9&4 POONAM 2026.04.02 02:43 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 8 5" ("" (% "-2=>""/5" &5$& G "H %8 6 ( 9&&"(% --((( ( 45 % / &(( " $ $ " ) ( & %% ( % $( '1( (&% $"((& $ % (&((( --55"C( " & / & 12* 3*!4& ++5 % 9; " 5 - % 1..6 4..,3*)+5 < ! " (( ('%/( :&"< C8 6- C8 6*&%( (( A3 "( " 68" POONAM 2026.04.02 02:43 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 9 % & " ( & (" (&" (" % (< < ( ( &%" C8 - *@9&$& % ( 6 $5 -* $(.(%" / "(45--01-223 "( (&( ( :& $ #( ( ( # $ % " % " #(# 9&@ "$ & ('- . " (% & $&($& " $ % (( "(( "8(& % / ((&((;($ % ( '1$ & % " C8 - * $ POONAM 2026.04.02 02:43 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 10 & && 9; 9 5 -217% ( ( / "C8J-C8J-+% (45% ( ? ($ 8 % ($ 6 "(:&" & C8 6- C8 6* & 8 ( % ( " 8( $& % &45 %$ %$ "($& ( OBSERVATIONS AND FINDINGS -> :%( " /& $%$ ( &( 8" "&" / "(((" (" /( ( 5 -+ ($& (&/9 $( +-(/5$-2-1 -0055( "/ "(" 5 ( 676 & * & 89 &6 &,:5 +$(& / " POONAM 2026.04.02 02:43 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 11 (/& ;&;& *89*6 &, :5 ! & & &897 &,:5::: ;: &&(/ "$ <(&<(" 0. &..;12 -3 % <! ( $ ( " &%6K6%9&$ % ( < ((" & " ( ( ) /9(" $($&(( ('- )%**01-210*--0-210 C8 6-E C8 6*(%(('*7 % ((( $ 5 (" ( (('- ( ! & (" ""@" " F " (A- B)$"8(("(( A* 4 &/$ "(F %#"( % C86-*C86-7$& ( POONAM 2026.04.02 02:43 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 12 / "&((% 68"( (5 ( (( $ " % " %$ % " $6( -7((6(" 8("#(( ( # $ & ( &D)(& & %:$&%$ &6(&"$ ( 9&$"&( %& % " ( < $ $ $% $ ("%&(" $"" : $ (; % ( " (% $ " A* I/ $ A> & A3 "( &(% ("% (&$" %$(" " ( $ % " (:"( ($("" (:< & "%"F"%"(($ POONAM 2026.04.02 02:43 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 13 " -=?" <(($ % 9 &$ " ( % (((+(9$-237+ 8 % 8$(9&$ " (&$(&%( %(((" % 4 I(5" %5(C -2=75# 5%-2>% $6-237$" %&9& "(/(" " %F(($ % ( $ & " < $); &(( $(( ( -15$($ ( &< ((;% 6 <"((( 45$ &%$""(& "8 ("" (" ("((&$(6 % "( $ (" (( % & % (("& POONAM 2026.04.02 02:43 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 14 ( $ ("4I " $%( 5;( 45%( % ;! & -2 45 " % & "/5" &5""$-2=> /'-*(-2=>" (% G "H:$$& (9& " "& "" "("F( "(($?( (% " (%<$ (("8% 9&@&$(( $ $ (( ) & -2=> ""$ "" % $ 6 ((&(( "$ 458 "" 1/ & 0; POONAM 2026.04.02 02:43 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 15 *0@9&$)(/9(" "& % ("( (" & "$ ( ( ( $ & ( "(8( "(< ( ( $ %( 6 %% < ('*7 ( $ C8 6-E C8 6*/&"((" ( (" "& :%$ A3"% &" ( &$ & "$ "L ? (& A*E A> '$ %(& && % *- 5 & (& ((;%( & 9&45$% & "" "( &($8" ( ":((/"$ POONAM 2026.04.02 02:43 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 16 "" " % / "9 $&%5; ( ( % *&; &3 &. & * ;.; ** 8<(& (( $" " 8( (/% /(%( ($% ( '1$ % " : (9&% < $$ " ) & %% ($ (" ((; C (" $8 ( ( ""8 ( & & " " *> :$ ( (&( % ! ●5%'*>-(-21- ((M $&&" ?=-055 POONAM 2026.04.02 02:43 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 17 ( $( /" ●5% '*>> ( -21- ( &D ( $&&"$&< " & ( " (" /"( (( "&" % % ( (&(((-- 55"( 6 ( /--556" "$ ""$("$"(6 ((< " )& 6 &%% (6( / & 12* 3*!4& ++5 $&% 9;"5- % 1..6 4..3*)+5 (( " & ( (% % $ (/ " POONAM 2026.04.02 02:43 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 18 *+. 45( %(& (( " ( 8%" ( 5& (%/ L G8%H& 8 (; ($& " %9& % ' ()*++ -&. / (+*+ "$&% "$ 5; ( / $("($ ((; "(( ( *3( (/ "(5& ( (% ( 45$ &% ( $"(& % "$ " ( /$ ( 8"<"( " / "(4 5$($(((" (" *7:%&(( $allowed / "--01-223 4 5/ "-+07-212 5 POONAM 2026.04.02 02:43 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 19 *= "$ $( $( 30.03.2026 (VIRINDER AGGARWAL) JUDGE , - . / 0 , - &/ 0 POONAM 2026.04.02 02:43 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document